YYoung and Profiting
← All episodes
Karissa Bodnar03 November 2023

Karissa Bodnar, Thrive Causemetics Founder: Entrepreneurship Gave Me The Freedom To Donate $150M in Value to Over 500 Charities

6Frameworks
9Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster24:30

Why Clean Beauty Is a Continuum, Not a Finished Label

Bodnar calls clean a buzz term unless a company defines what it means and keeps improving. Thrive consults medical and regulatory experts while balancing cleaner ingredients with effectiveness, treating health and sustainability as evolving technical work rather than a permanent badge.

  • Each company must define what clean means for its products
  • Cleaner and more sustainable are continuing directions
  • Medical and regulatory expertise informs formula decisions
  • Removing ingredients cannot become an excuse for poor performance

clean is is a bit of a buzz term to be fully transparent

Karissa Bodnar · 24:30

sustainability it's a Continuum so we're never finished trying to be cleaner

Karissa Bodnar · 24:30
#clean beauty#sustainability#product safety#innovation

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take58:30

Profiting in Life Means Moving Toward Discomfort

Bodnar defines profiting beyond money as deep joy, purpose, connection, and inner peace. She argues that fear and discomfort can point toward the growth, conflict resolution, or accomplishment that produces joy on the other side, while also acknowledging that overwork cost her friendships in her twenties.

  • Joy and purpose define profit beyond financial results
  • Discomfort can precede growth and accomplishment
  • Team members moving through conflict can produce meaningful change
  • Friendship and community are forms of profit that work can crowd out

profiting in life is is going towards that disc comfort so that you can feel the joy that's on the other side

Karissa Bodnar · 59:00

to me profiting is having that inner joy and that peace

Karissa Bodnar · 60:00
#joy#discomfort#friendship#purpose

Story· 5

Story07:00

The High School Monopoly Board That Raised $25,000

Bodnar describes selling advertising squares to local businesses to finance a custom Monopoly board called Twin City opoly. The project taught her upselling, salesmanship, and product development while restoring a sense of purpose during a difficult period in high school.

  • Local advertising paid the product's cost of goods
  • Premium square placements created an upsell
  • The finished board raised $25,000 for Future Business Leaders of America
  • Holding a commercial product changed her confidence and motivation

I learned upselling I learned salesperson ship I learned product development through creating that Monopoly board

Karissa Bodnar · 08:00

raised $25,000 for the local chapter

Karissa Bodnar · 09:00
#student business#fundraising#sales#purpose
Story10:30

The Grandmothers Who Taught Tenacity and Self-Belief

Bodnar credits her grandmothers with shaping both resilience and confidence. Ruth survived Nazi Germany, immigrated, and built a working life without excuses, while Jackie deliberately praised strength and intelligence rather than appearance.

  • Ruth modeled perseverance through immigration and work
  • Jackie used spoken affirmations before they were culturally common
  • She redirected praise from appearance toward intelligence and potential
  • The lessons remained part of Bodnar's leadership identity

there was no excuses with her

Karissa Bodnar · 11:00

tell her she's smart tell her she's going places

Karissa Bodnar · 11:30
#mentorship#family#confidence#resilience
Story16:00

The Executive Who Told Bodnar to Change the Industry

After L'Oreal acquired Clarisonic, Bodnar approached executive Carol Hamilton and asked about her path through beauty. Hamilton's encouragement gave the young employee permission to imagine changing the industry rather than simply advancing within it.

  • Bodnar directly approached a senior executive she admired
  • Hamilton framed industry experience as its own education
  • A mentor's belief expanded what Bodnar thought was possible
  • Bodnar sees her success as built on earlier women's work

I may not have an MBA but I have an MBA in the beauty industry

Karissa Bodnar · 17:00

I paved the way so that you could change the industry

Karissa Bodnar · 18:30
#mentorship#beauty industry#confidence#career
Story20:00

How Losing a Friend Put Giving at Thrive's Core

The death of Bodnar's friend Christie prompted her to take stock of what her work contributed to the world. She decided that philanthropy was the missing part of her beauty career and began with one product, one cancer charity, and a goal of eventually donating a full face of makeup and skincare.

  • Loss forced a review of daily work and long-term direction
  • Beauty became a vehicle for confidence and human connection
  • The giving program started with one product and one charity
  • The model later expanded across causes and all 50 states

those are the moments where you take stock of your life and think about okay well what am I doing every day to contribute to…

Karissa Bodnar · 20:30

I started with with one product and I started with one charity and one cause

Karissa Bodnar · 22:00
#purpose#grief#philanthropy#founder story
Story35:30

The $38,000 Sales Day That Still Did Not Mean Thrive Had Made It

A five-minute Today show feature took Thrive from zero sales the previous day to about $38,000 in one day. Bodnar initially felt the company had made it, but the immediate drop afterward exposed the difference between a press spike and a durable customer engine.

  • Early retail pitches repeatedly failed
  • Press created a dramatic but temporary sales event
  • Bodnar fulfilled the orders from her apartment
  • The drop forced her to build an online community one relationship at a time

we did like $38,000 in sales that day and I fulfilled all those orders out of my apartment

Karissa Bodnar · 36:30

the challenge with that though is that it drops off

Karissa Bodnar · 36:30
#public relations#sales spike#community#founder story

Tool· 1

Tool38:30

Using Website Behavior When Research Budgets Are Small

Bodnar used the Lucky Orange Shopify app to see where visitors engaged with ingredient information and where they might be confused. She stresses that this is directional evidence, but it gave an early-stage company an affordable way to decide what to investigate and update.

  • Behavioral tools can reveal where visitors engage
  • Observed friction provides directional rather than definitive evidence
  • Small brands can learn before they can afford formal studies
  • Fast website updates shorten the feedback cycle

you can see where consumers are engaging on your website

Karissa Bodnar · 39:00

it does give you directional information on where consumers may be confused on your website

Karissa Bodnar · 39:00
#shopify#analytics#user research#ecommerce

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway53:30

Measure Impact One Changed Life at a Time

Although Thrive cites a large total value of donations, Bodnar returns to individual relationships when defining success. Comparing her apartment-stage giving with companies donating millions once discouraged her, while focusing on one person made meaningful action possible at any scale.

  • Large aggregate numbers can discourage an early founder
  • Individual stories keep impact emotionally concrete
  • Beneficiaries and community members also change the founder
  • A small act can still satisfy a meaningful definition of success

it's about one life at a time

Karissa Bodnar · 55:00

we always have an opportunity to show up and be the change that we want to be in the world

Karissa Bodnar · 55:00
#impact#purpose#philanthropy#relationships