YYoung and Profiting
← All episodes
Katy Milkman01 August 2022

Katy Milkman: The Science of Change

9Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Self-Mastery4 steps

Commitment Devices

Voluntarily fine your future self to keep it from making impulsive mistakes.

Read →
Self-Mastery4 steps

Emergency Reserves

Set a tough goal, then grant yourself a few 'get out of jail free' chits to beat the what-the-hell effect.

Read →
Productivity4 steps

Flexible Habits Over Rigid Ones

Build habits with some variability so a missed window doesn't collapse the whole habit.

Read →
Leadership4 steps

Gamification That Works

Game mechanics motivate when you opt in — and backfire as forced fun when they're imposed.

Read →
Marketing4 steps

Reserved-For-You Messaging

Tell people something has been set aside just for them and the endowment effect makes them want it.

Read →
Self-Mastery4 steps

Temptation Bundling

Pair a chore you avoid with a pleasure you crave, and you'll start craving the chore.

Read →
Influence4 steps

The Advice Club (Giving Advice to Get Ahead)

Coaching someone else who's struggling with your goal boosts your own confidence and follow-through.

Read →
Mindset4 steps

The Fresh Start Effect

Time a new goal to a chapter break — a Monday, a birthday, a move — and optimism does the lifting.

Read →
Strategy4 steps

The Pre-Mortem (Obstacle-Based Planning)

Before you start, imagine the goal has failed and name every reason why — then plan around each.

Read →

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster11:00

Gamification Doesn't Always Work — It Depends on Motivation

Gamification fails when it feels forced, especially in workplace settings. It succeeds when individuals are intrinsically motivated and the game elements align with personal goals, such as earning badges on Wikipedia for volunteer contributions.

  • Forced gamification can backfire and feel inauthentic.
  • Works best when users opt in and are already motivated.
  • Simple rewards like recognition boost engagement.
  • Leaderboards and points don’t help if the activity feels imposed.

“When it's being imposed on you... it can actually backfire.”

Katy Milkman · 11:15
#gamification#intrinsic motivation#behavior design#employee engagement
Myth Buster27:30

Rigidity Hurts Habits — Flexibility Builds Resilience

Being too rigid with habits—like always exercising at the same time—makes them brittle. Flexible routines allow for missed windows and lead to more consistent long-term adherence.

  • Consistent timing builds fragile habits.
  • Flexible timing leads to more robust outcomes.
  • Life disruptions are inevitable; flexibility accommodates them.
  • Variability in timing increases overall habit strength.

“If they miss their best window they still get around to doing it and overall that leads to more robust and lasting habits.”

Katy Milkman · 28:45
#habit formation#flexibility#behavior change#consistency

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take35:30

Negative Thinking Beats Positive Thinking for Success

Optimism alone isn't enough. Anticipating obstacles—called a 'pre-mortem'—is more effective than positive affirmations. Planning what could go wrong increases preparedness and follow-through.

  • Positive thinking often ignores real barriers.
  • Pre-mortems imagine failure to identify risks.
  • Obstacle planning improves goal achievement.
  • Used in engineering and behavioral science.

“If you don't plan for what can go wrong... you are much less likely to succeed.”

Katy Milkman · 36:10
#pre-mortem#obstacle planning#negative thinking#resilience

Explainer· 4

Explainer07:30

Why Enjoyable Paths Lead to Better Goal Achievement

People persist longer toward their goals when they enjoy the process, even if it's less efficient. Choosing a fun path—like a Zumba class with a friend instead of a punishing stairmaster—increases long-term adherence because enjoyment combats present bias and procrastination.

  • Enjoyment increases persistence toward goals.
  • Pleasurable methods lead to better long-term outcomes than efficient but painful ones.
  • Present bias makes people abandon difficult routines quickly.
  • Fun activities encourage repeated engagement.

“We do better when we look for a path that we'll enjoy more even if it's a little bit more circuitous.”

Katy Milkman · 07:55
#behavioral science#goal achievement#present bias#habit formation
Explainer07:30

How Temptation Bundling Makes Chores Appealing

Temptation bundling pairs something enjoyable with a task you avoid, making the chore more appealing. For example, only allowing yourself indulgent entertainment while exercising can make gym visits something to look forward to.

  • Pairing pleasures with chores increases motivation.
  • Example: Only watch favorite shows while at the gym.
  • Can be applied to household tasks, meals, or social obligations.
  • Transforms dreaded activities into anticipated ones.

“I only let myself enjoy indulgent entertainment while I was exercising at the gym and that meant I started craving trips to the gym.”

Katy Milkman · 08:55
#temptation bundling#behavior change#habit formation#motivation
Explainer23:30

How Fresh Starts Help Us Change

People are more likely to pursue goals after temporal landmarks like New Year’s Day, birthdays, or Mondays. These moments create a psychological 'new chapter,' boosting optimism and motivation to become a 'new self.'

  • Temporal landmarks trigger fresh start mindsets.
  • Examples: New Year’s, birthdays, start of a week.
  • People feel they can leave past failures behind.
  • Linked to increased gym visits and goal searches online.

“Those discontinuities give us this sense that we can change.”

Katy Milkman · 26:15
#fresh starts#temporal landmarks#motivation#behavior change
Explainer51:00

What Nudging Really Means

Nudging uses psychology to guide people toward better decisions without changing incentives or removing freedom. Examples include default enrollment in retirement plans or framing a vaccine as 'reserved' to increase uptake.

  • Nudges preserve freedom of choice.
  • Do not involve payments or mandates.
  • Use defaults, framing, and social norms.
  • Most effective when aligned with existing intentions.

“A nudge would be pushing people... toward a decision that they already would favor if they had all the time in the world to analyze…”

Katy Milkman · 51:20
#nudging#behavioral economics#choice architecture#public policy

Story· 1

Story40:30

Struggling People Can Help Themselves by Giving Advice

Research shows that people struggling with goals improve when asked to mentor others. The act of giving advice boosts confidence, encourages introspection, and creates accountability to follow their own wisdom.

  • Giving advice increases self-confidence.
  • Forces deeper reflection on one’s own challenges.
  • Creates hypocrisy aversion—wanting to follow your own advice.
  • Proven in students, salespeople, and high schoolers.

“Even students who are getting C's... actually had a lot of wisdom about what was going wrong.”

Katy Milkman · 40:50
#advice giving#mentorship#self-efficacy#behavior change

Tool· 4

Tool17:00

Commitment Devices: Self-Imposed Rules That Work

Commitment devices are self-created constraints that increase accountability, such as putting money on the line to quit smoking. Studies show they boost success rates by 30%, especially when tied to real consequences.

  • Self-imposed penalties increase follow-through.
  • Example: Losing $500 if you fail a smoking test after six months.
  • Websites exist to help enforce these commitments.
  • Works because people take financial stakes seriously.

“People who also have that commitment device quit at a 30% higher rate.”

Katy Milkman · 18:30
#commitment devices#accountability#behavior change#self-control
Tool30:00

Use Emergency Reserves to Avoid the 'What the Hell' Effect

The 'what the hell' effect occurs when one slip leads to total abandonment of a goal. Allowing for 'emergency reserves'—like two missed days in a weekly goal—prevents collapse and maintains motivation.

  • Failing one day doesn’t mean failing the whole goal.
  • Emergency reserves act as 'get out of jail free' cards.
  • Better than lowering standards; maintains high expectations.
  • Used in apps like Duolingo with streak freezes.

“Give yourself these emergency chits as opposed to a wimpier goal that isn't going to push you.”

Katy Milkman · 31:45
#what the hell effect#self-control#habit resilience#goal setting
Tool43:30

Form an Advice Club to Achieve Your Goals

Creating a group of peers with similar goals—where you exchange solicited advice—boosts confidence, clarity, and accountability. The advice giver benefits as much as the receiver.

  • Advice clubs build social cohesion and insight.
  • Easier to solve others’ problems objectively.
  • Solutions become reusable for your own future issues.
  • Works in professional and personal goal settings.

“Every time they ping me about a challenge... I get huge benefits from thinking through their challenge.”

Katy Milkman · 44:45
#advice club#peer support#goal achievement#accountability
Tool48:30

“Your Vaccine Is Reserved” — A Powerful Nudge

Telling people a vaccine was “reserved for you” increased uptake by leveraging the endowment effect—the psychological tendency to value things we believe already belong to us.

  • “Reserved for you” language implies ownership.
  • Triggers the endowment effect and perceived scarcity.
  • Implies endorsement from healthcare providers.
  • Worked across pharmacies and doctor visits.

“A vaccine is reserved for you... it feels like it already belongs to you.”

Katy Milkman · 48:50
#nudging#endowment effect#behavioral science#public health