YYoung and Profiting
← All episodes
Marissa Orr21 December 2020

Marissa Orr: Lean Out - Women, Power and the Workplace

3Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster02:30

Lean Out Says Women Are Not the Problem

Orr contrasts Lean In's emphasis on changing women's behavior with her claim that the corporate system creates the gender gap. A scarcity-based hierarchy disproportionately rewards people motivated by competition, power, and win-lose games.

  • Lean In attributes part of the gap to internalized cultural constraints
  • Lean Out locates the primary problem in corporate structure
  • A narrowing hierarchy creates a zero-sum competition
  • The system rewards certain motivations rather than superior competence

women are not broken or deficient but the system in the corporate world is such that um it rewards certain traits that men have

Marissa Orr · 04:00

the system is set up as a zero-sum competition

Marissa Orr · 04:30
#gender gap#lean out#corporate hierarchy
Myth Buster29:30

Remote Work Can Increase Performative Busyness

Working from home does not automatically make evaluation results-oriented. Where objective outcomes remain absent, workers may compensate for lost face time with more video, email, and longer hours, creating extra visibility work without extra productive work.

  • Many remote workers report longer hours
  • Employees use video and email to prove they are present
  • Visible activity can expand without productive output
  • The most visibility-driven colleague can reset the benchmark for everyone

it's increased the amount of work but not increased the amount of productive work

Marissa Orr · 32:00

who's ever more motivated to be seen as the good one sets the new benchmark for which everyone else on the team now has to…

Marissa Orr · 32:30
#remote work#productivity#visibility

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take15:30

The Information Economy Still Runs on Industrial-Age Hierarchy

Orr says top-down corporate hierarchy made sense for industrial manufacturing, assembly lines, and scaled production. Creativity and innovation need a different environment, yet companies retain structures built centuries ago.

  • Industrial production benefited from a chain of command
  • Modern knowledge work depends on creativity and innovation
  • Top-down power structures can suppress those capabilities
  • Legacy organizational structure continues after its original context changed

we're in an information economy now and the entire world has changed you need creativity and innovation which don't thrive in a top-down power structure

Marissa Orr · 16:00
#information economy#hierarchy#innovation
Hot Take57:30

Lean In Can Help Some Women Without Speaking for All Women

Orr says she avoided major backlash partly because the book tries to represent competing perspectives fairly. She accepts that Lean In may be useful to women pursuing corporate executive roles while rejecting the assumption that all women share that destination.

  • Different approaches can share the goal of helping women
  • Lean In offers relevant experience for aspiring corporate executives
  • Women do not form a monolithic group with identical ambitions
  • Disagreement should not be equated with opposition to women

if sheldon sandberg and i have different ways of doing that then that shouldn't be controversial if our goal is the same

Marissa Orr · 59:30

women are not some big monolithic brain where we all want the same things and want to get to the same places

Marissa Orr · 60:00
#lean in#disagreement#feminism

Explainer· 2

Explainer06:00

Why Likeability Does Not Drive Corporate Promotion

Orr argues that the corporate hierarchy surfaces aggressive, dominance-oriented traits while penalizing agreeableness in both women and men. Women who violate stereotypes may face social punishment, but that does not necessarily make them less likely to advance.

  • Agreeable and relationship-focused workers can be disadvantaged
  • Aggressive women may face backlash while still being promoted
  • Men acting outside the stereotypical male profile can face an even larger advancement penalty
  • The decisive variable is which traits win the corporate game

the bossy more aggressive women were the ones getting promoted

Marissa Orr · 06:30

it's not even a gender issue it's a matter of what traits and characteristics lend themselves to winning this particular game

Marissa Orr · 10:00
#personality#promotion#stereotypes
Explainer55:00

How Zero-Sum Competition Turns Relationships Into Weapons

Orr argues that many women derive strength and social currency from relationships when working toward a shared goal. A zero-sum workplace can erode those bonds and encourage covert relational aggression, while direct aggression between men is more culturally expected.

  • Shared goals can make relationships a source of power
  • Zero-sum competition damages those relationships
  • Relational aggression can appear covert and underhanded
  • The environment shapes behaviour rather than proving women are inherently hostile

when women are working together toward a common goal their relationships are their power and their currency

Marissa Orr · 55:30

when you put women in a zero-sum competitive scenario it erodes the very fabric of their relationships

Marissa Orr · 55:30
#competition#relationships#workplace culture

Story· 4

Story11:30

The Google Personality Test That Exposed the Executive Profile

A Google team exercise classified Orr as relationship-oriented Earth Green and competitive colleagues as Fiery Red. When she asked about the senior executive team, nine of ten were Red, revealing how the hierarchy selected for appetite for power and control.

  • Earth Green prioritizes harmony, relationships, and helping people
  • Fiery Red prioritizes competition, power, control, and results
  • Nine of ten senior executives were Red
  • Authority can conflict with the relationships that motivate Green personalities

nine out of ten were green just kidding they were red

Marissa Orr · 13:00

authority and relationships are in tension with each other you dial one up the other goes down

Marissa Orr · 13:30
#google#personality types#motivation
Story33:30

How Corporate Phoniness Became the Lean Out Lecture Series

Orr's frustration with performative women's leadership programs combined with her rediscovery of writing and presenting. She began with five friends in a conference room, gradually found more audiences, and eventually turned the lecture series into a book and speaking career.

  • Women's workshops began to feel careerist and inauthentic
  • Writing and performing her own material unlocked a neglected creative drive
  • The first audience was only five friends
  • Commitment deepened when the series became an emotional lifeline at Facebook

the anger combined with you know sort of discovering a little bit of of what i liked um i just felt compelled

Marissa Orr · 36:30

at first it was a you know five of my friends in a conference room

Marissa Orr · 37:00
#lean out#speaking#career change
Story42:30

Facebook Found and Censored a Nearly Unread Blog Post

Orr describes Facebook's tight control over employee messaging, extending even to an unrelated innovation talk and a tiny personal Medium blog. Corporate communications found an article that did not name Facebook and asked her to remove it, after which she republished it under her initials.

  • Google had tolerated respectful internal debate and outside writing
  • Facebook required approval for an unrelated medical-conference deck
  • The Medium post had almost no audience and did not identify her employer
  • Orr restored her full name after leaving Facebook

one day i got this email from corporate comms and facebook to tell me to take it down

Marissa Orr · 45:30

first thing i did after facebook was put my name on that sucker

Marissa Orr · 46:30
#facebook#employee speech#culture
Story48:00

From a Nine-Month Recruitment Courtship to a Retaliatory PIP

A senior Facebook executive spent months recruiting Orr with flattery, then abruptly ostracized and undermined her after Orr met Sheryl Sandberg. Following an HR investigation triggered by someone else's report, Orr was placed on a performance plan focused partly on her relationship with that same executive.

  • The recruitment relationship felt like a long courtship
  • The treatment changed in Orr's third week
  • A meeting with Sheryl Sandberg was interpreted as office politics
  • The PIP followed an investigation despite an anti-retaliation promise

my third week at facebook she just totally turned on me

Marissa Orr · 49:30

the biggest reason for it was my failure to develop good relationships with kimberly and her team

Marissa Orr · 52:30
#facebook#bullying#retaliation

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway54:00

Why Orr Waited to Be Fired Instead of Quitting

As a financially independent single mother of three, Orr considered an immediate resignation irresponsible. She kept working on the book while preserving salary and stock, intending to use the eventual payout as runway for a bet on herself.

  • Family financial responsibility constrained the exit
  • She worked on the next path before employment ended
  • Salary and stock became transition capital
  • The delayed exit was strategic rather than passive

what i did was work on the book knowing i was going to be fired to maintain to get the salary and the stock and…

Marissa Orr · 54:30

save up as much as i can so that i could live on that money while i try and forge this new path

Marissa Orr · 55:00
#career transition#runway#single parent
Takeaway62:00

Marissa Orr's Secret to Profiting: Self-Awareness

Orr closes by naming self-awareness and honesty with herself as her secret to profiting in life. Staying true to herself begins with the continuing work of discovering what that identity means.

  • Self-awareness is the foundation
  • Honesty with oneself matters
  • Authenticity requires ongoing discovery

my secret to profiting in life is self-awareness

Marissa Orr · 62:00

my whole thing in life is to stay true to who i am and figuring out what that even means

Marissa Orr · 62:00
#self-awareness#authenticity