YYoung and Profiting
← All episodes
Dr. Maya Shankar09 August 2021

Dr. Maya Shankar: The Science of Decision Making

10Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster24:30

Change Isn't Just About Bouncing Back—It's About Becoming New

Dr. Shankar challenges the idea that resilience means returning to who you were. Instead, she argues that change often leads to reinvention—revealing new strengths, values, and perspectives. The 'end of history illusion' makes us think we won’t change, but change forces internal transformation.

  • Resilience is often seen as bouncing back, but reinvention is about becoming someone new.
  • Change reveals hidden beliefs and abilities we didn’t know we had.
  • The 'end of history illusion' makes us think we’re finished evolving, but we’re always changing.
  • Big change can accelerate personal growth and self-discovery.

We sometimes forget that we ourselves change. When a big change happens to us, it also inspires lasting change within us.

Dr. Maya Shankar · 26:30
#resilience#growth#transformation#psychology

Explainer· 3

Explainer02:30

Why Identity Paralysis Happens and How to Overcome It

Dr. Maya Shankar explains that identity paralysis occurs when a major life change strips away the roles we associate with our sense of self, leaving us unsure of who we are. Instead of defining yourself by what you do, she suggests identifying your deeper 'why'—the core values and passions behind your actions. This allows you to remain grounded even when external roles change.

  • Identity paralysis happens when a sudden change removes your defining role (e.g., career, relationship).
  • We often tie our self-worth to external labels like job titles or roles.
  • Defining yourself by your 'why'—such as human connection or helping others—creates a more resilient identity.
  • Asking 'What do I love about what I do?' helps uncover your enduring values.

One way that we can get out of identity paralysis is to define yourself not simply by what you do, but by why you do…

Dr. Maya Shankar · 04:30
#identity#change#self-worth#resilience
Explainer08:30

Why Uncertainty Feels Worse Than Bad News

Our brains are wired to fear uncertainty more than negative outcomes. Dr. Shankar shares research showing people are more stressed by a 50% chance of an electric shock than a 100% chance, illustrating how ambiguity is more psychologically taxing than certainty—even if the outcome is bad.

  • The brain dislikes uncertainty more than negative outcomes.
  • A 50% chance of a shock causes more stress than a 100% chance.
  • Change is disorienting because it removes predictability and control.
  • This explains why sudden change feels so destabilizing.

We are more stressed when we're told we have a 50% chance of getting an electric shock than when we're told we have a 100%…

Dr. Maya Shankar · 08:45
#neuroscience#uncertainty#psychology#stress
Explainer17:30

How Moral Elevation Expands Your Possible Selves

Witnessing extraordinary kindness, courage, or resilience in others—what psychologists call 'moral elevation'—can inspire us to imagine new versions of ourselves. Dr. Shankar explains how seeing someone defy expectations can break mental constraints and unlock potential.

  • Moral elevation is the warm feeling we get from witnessing moral beauty.
  • It expands our belief in what’s possible for ourselves.
  • Dwayne, a man in prison, was inspired by a fellow inmate’s dignity to become a poet and later a Yale Law graduate.
  • Stories of resilience can reshape our self-concept, even across different life experiences.

When we witness someone else's moral beauty, it actually cracks open our own imagination about what is possible for us.

Dr. Maya Shankar · 18:15
#inspiration#morality#resilience#identity

Story· 2

Story13:30

Grieving a Future That Never Was

Dr. Shankar shares how she grieved the loss of motherhood—a future self she had always imagined. She introduces the psychological concept of 'possible selves,' including hoped-for, feared, and expected selves, and how change forces us to confront and revise these internal visions.

  • We can grieve not just lost realities, but lost future identities.
  • Possible selves include who we hope to be, fear becoming, or expect to become.
  • Societal norms can limit our imagination of what’s possible.
  • Change can reveal hidden beliefs and open space for new identities.

In many ways, I've written it for people who are not just in the throws of change, but are anticipating a potential future and are…

Dr. Maya Shankar · 13:30
#grief#future-self#motherhood#identity
Story35:00

How Amnesia Helped a Woman Reclaim Her Cultural Pride

Dr. Shankar shares the story of Ingred, a woman who lost her memories in a biking accident and later rediscovered her Colombian heritage without the shame she once felt. This allowed her to embrace and share her family’s stories with pride, free from past biases.

  • Ingred lost her memories and returned to her cultural roots without shame.
  • She fell in love with her family’s stories before remembering she once felt embarrassed by them.
  • Her story shows how beliefs are not fixed truths but can be reevaluated.
  • Change can create space to question and revise inherited values.

She starts sharing them liberally. And only a few weeks later does the memory resurface that she had once been ashamed of those stories. But…

Dr. Maya Shankar · 35:50
#culture#identity#memory#self-discovery

Tool· 5

Tool37:30

How a Self-Affirmation Exercise Restores Stability

After a miscarriage, Dr. Shankar’s husband suggested listing things they were grateful for. Though initially resistant, she found the exercise helped her see her life as multifaceted and rich beyond one goal. This self-affirmation practice can stabilize identity during upheaval.

  • List identities and values that are still intact, even after loss.
  • Focus on roles and relationships not threatened by the change.
  • This builds psychological stability and self-worth.
  • Can be done in five minutes and is helpful in any life stage.

I started to realize that my life was so much richer and more multifaceted than I'd given myself credit for.

Dr. Maya Shankar · 39:00
#gratitude#mental-health#self-worth#resilience
Tool42:00

Use Mental Time Travel to Reduce Rumination

To break cycles of rumination after job loss or other setbacks, Dr. Shankar recommends 'mental time travel'—asking how you’ll feel about the situation in 5 years. This creates psychological distance and perspective, reducing emotional intensity.

  • Travel backward to recall past resilience.
  • Travel forward to gain perspective on current pain.
  • Asking 'How will I feel in 5 years?' reduces present suffering.
  • Helps reframe setbacks as temporary and transformative.

How am I going to feel about the same situation 5 days from now, 5 years from now, 15 years from now?

Dr. Maya Shankar · 42:45
#rumination#perspective#healing#time
Tool47:00

How to Move Forward Without Closure After a Breakup

Dr. Shankar explains that closure is often 'fool’s gold'—unattainable but deeply desired. Instead of fixating on answers, she recommends finding community with others who’ve experienced loss and seeking awe-inspiring experiences to gain perspective.

  • Closure is often unattainable; learning to live with uncertainty is key.
  • The Museum of Broken Relationships helped one woman feel less alone.
  • Awe—through nature, art, or moral beauty—reduces self-focus and anxiety.
  • We can learn from people whose stories don’t mirror ours but share emotional truths.

The idea of closure was fool's gold. And so what she actually had to do was to become more comfortable with the idea of living…

Dr. Maya Shankar · 48:50
#breakup#closure#community#healing
Tool54:00

Use Temptation Bundling to Stay Motivated

Dr. Shankar shares how she used temptation bundling—pairing a hard task with a pleasurable one—to write her book. By only allowing herself candy during writing sessions, she made the task more appealing and sustainable.

  • Pair a challenging task with an enjoyable reward.
  • Only allow the reward during the task to build positive association.
  • Examples: favorite music only during workouts, special snacks only during work.
  • Makes hard goals more attractive and repeatable.

I would allow myself to eat as much of these little coffee chews as I wanted during my writing sessions, but I was never allowed…

Dr. Maya Shankar · 54:20
#motivation#productivity#habits#self-control
Tool58:30

How a Daily Ritual Creates Stability in Chaos

Dr. Shankar shares how making Indian-style tea every morning—packing it while traveling—creates a sense of control and grounding. Small, consistent rituals signal to the brain that some things remain within our power, even when everything else feels uncertain.

  • A daily ritual provides psychological stability.
  • Doing it consistently, even when you don’t want to, reinforces agency.
  • It’s a tangible act of self-care and control.
  • Simple practices can have deep emotional impact.

There are still some things that are fully in our control that we can introduce into our lives no matter what.

Dr. Maya Shankar · 59:00
#ritual#control#anxiety#routine

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway64:00

Helping Others Is the Best Way to Help Yourself

Dr. Shankar shares research and her personal belief that helping others is one of the most effective ways to boost well-being. Small acts of kindness—like smiling at a stranger—can reduce loneliness and increase self-worth.

  • Helping others boosts our own mental health and sense of purpose.
  • Acts don’t need to be large—small gestures matter.
  • It combats the loneliness epidemic by fostering connection.
  • We see ourselves as valuable when we contribute to others.

Helping others is one of the best ways to boost our own well-being.

Dr. Maya Shankar · 64:15
#kindness#wellbeing#community#purpose